Maximal running shoes may increase injury risk to some runners

Press Release:

BEND, Ore. – Lower leg pain and injuries have long been a problem for runners, but research at Oregon State University-Cascades has shown that one type of running shoe may increase such risks for some runners.

Researchers in the Functional Orthopedic Research Center of Excellence (FORCE) Lab compared the biomechanics associated with “maximal” and “neutral” running shoes in tests with 15 female runners. The study concluded that runners experienced a higher impact peak and increased loading rate with the “maximal” shoes. Increases in both factors are associated with a greater likelihood of injury, such as plantar fasciitis and tibial stress fractures.

The study was published in The Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine and is believed to be the first rigorous analysis of impacts associated with maximal shoes.

Maximal running shoes feature increased cushioning, particularly in the forefoot region of the midsole, and have gained popularity since being introduced in 2010. More than 20 varieties of maximal shoes are on the market.

Runners wearing maximal shoes, the researchers wrote, have reported feeling the extra cushion after running two to three miles. As a result, the researchers did not expect to find increases in impact peak or loading rate in runners wearing maximal shoes.

In the FORCE Lab study, researchers evaluated the impacts on runners’ feet and legs before and after a simulated 5,000 meter (about 3 miles) run on a treadmill. Each subject wore a neutral running shoe (New Balance 880) for one test and then, after a seven to 10-day waiting period, repeated the procedure with a maximal shoe (Hoke One One Bondi 4). In each test, 3D movements and forces were measured by monitoring reflective markers placed on the runners’ shoes and legs and by having the subjects run over a “force plate” that recorded the forces being applied as the runner’s foot hit the surface.

“We were surprised by these results,” said Christine Pollard, director of the FORCE Lab and an associate professor of kinesiology. “We thought we would see the opposite. Typically, increased cushioning results in a reduction in the impact peak and loading rate of the vertical ground reaction force. We suspect that the large amount of cushioning across the entire midsole caused the runners to rely more on the shoe than on their own internal structures to attenuate these forces.”

The study also evaluated the degree of “peak eversion,” the outward turning of the foot, a factor associated with injury risk. The researchers found no difference between the maximal and neutral shoes.

The research is a first step in gathering evidence on the effects of maximal running shoes on runners’ injury risks, said Pollard, who is also a licensed physical therapist. Maximal shoes are becoming very popular, but without controlled studies, clinicians have been unable to make science-based recommendations to runners.

Pollard said she expects that a study with male runners might produce different results. “We know that gender differences in running biomechanics do exist,” she added.

Advertisement:

Bestseller No. 1
New Balance Men's 520 V6 Running Shoe, Gunmetal/Team Royal, 11.5 M US
  • Diverse Performance: With a durable rubber outsole and ties to high-end performance running shoes, the 520v6 delivers lasting comfort and a quality fit whether you’re running laps or running errands
  • Impressive Fit: The modern upper on these fitness shoes is made of no-sew engineered mesh, creating a sophisticated style that also offers breathability and a comfortable fit
  • Durability and Comfort: Featuring a strong rubber outsole for durability and a molded footbed for underfoot comfort, these runners are sure to become your new daily kicks
  • Designed for All-Day Wear: This New Balance sneaker is truly a premium underfoot comfort experience, offering a great fit and feel that can take you from morning to night
  • New Balance Running Shoes With a Fresh, Attractive Design: Add an exclamation mark to your outfit with these fitness shoes, which prove that functional can also be fashionable
Bestseller No. 2
Vibram Women's V-Run Running Shoe Blue/Blue 10-10.5
  • Product runs slightly large. Please size down 1 size from your actual VFF size!
  • Vibram VI-LITE features the ultimate in lightweight, shock absorption cushioning, for maximum energy conservation.
  • Vibram XS RUN provides a maximal stable hardness across a broad temperature range and the softness of the compound allows for expansive ground contac
  • Vibram MONT compound formulation is optimized for mountaineering, treking, acrobatic, works and motorbike racing.
Bestseller No. 3
Brooks Womens Levitate 2 Running Shoe - Pink/Black/Aqua - B - 9.5
  • SHOE SIZE: "B" = Medium width
  • FOOT SUPPORT: Ideal for runners with a medium to high arch looking for neutral support.
  • ENERGIZED FEEL: Delivers a responsive and springy ride to add extra lift to your stride without compromising support or speed.
  • ENERGIZED CUSHIONING: With the most energy return of leading performance running shoes, the DNA AMP midsole technology in Levitate 2 gives you back more of the effort you put in.
  • INTUITIVE FIT, INCOGNITO COMFORT: The inside of the highly adaptable Fit Knit upper holds a host of comfort features to keep you running at your best.
SaleBestseller No. 4
Brooks Womens Levitate 4 Running Shoe - Black/Ebony/Rose Gold - B - 8.5
  • THIS WOMEN'S SHOE IS FOR: The Levitate 4 is perfect for runners who want a shoe that helps them by giving energy back with each step, the Levitate 4's DNA AMP is now 20% lighter so our highest energy return foam is better than ever.
  • ENERGIZED CUSHIONING: Now 20% lighter, our DNA AMP midsole technology lets your foot spring off the ground with each step for speedy, efficient energy return.
  • SECURE, SOCK-LIFE FIT: We updated the Fit Knit Upper to provide a close-to-foot fit that’s lighter, softer, and more breathable than before. The Levitate 4 runs more shallow and provides a slightly more snug fit. If looking for a more roomy fit, Brooks recommends sizing up by 1/2 a size
  • QUICK TRANSITIONS: An updated arrow-point pattern on the outsole lets your foot move from heel to toe quickly, enhancing the shoe’s springy feel.
  • WEAR TESTERS SAY: “ I loved the energy I felt when running in these. Great cushion and ride.”
Bestseller No. 5
Nike Women's Trail Running Shoes, Multicolour (Pink Blast/True Berry/Atmosphere Grey, 5.5 UK
  • A Full-Length Nike React Midsole Balances Cushioning And Responsiveness With Lightweight, Durable Foam That Delivers An Extremely Smooth Ride.
  • A Transparent Upper Evokes The Look Of Fast, While The Inner Sleeve And A Low Collar Conform To Your Foot In A Racing Fit.
  • A Carbon Fiber Plate Inside The Midsole Can Shrink Or Expand The Amount Of Fiber Layers For Maximal Flexibility In Your Stride.
  • An Arch Band Attached To Laces Helps Take Pressure Off Your Instep.
Bestseller No. 7
Vibram FiveFingers Women's V-Run Minimalist Running Shoe (Grey/Yellow, Numeric_8)
  • Vibram VI-LITE features the ultimate in lightweight, shock absorption cushioning, for maximum energy conservation.
  • Vibram XS RUN provides a maximal stable hardness across a broad temperature range and the softness of the compound allows for expansive ground contact adn grip across lug surfaces. XS RUN also provides high grip on smooth surfaces.
  • Vibram MONT compound formulation is optimized for mountaineering, treking, acrobatic, works and motorbike racing. MONT is used to conquer the highest peaks in the world by offering the highest reliability on the most difficult terrain at low temperatures.
  • Sole Spec: INSOLE: 2mm EVA + Drilex Sockliner MIDSOLE: 4mm EVA RUBBER: 2.5mm
  • Upper Material: Polyester Lycra Stretch Mesh + Polyester Microfiber
SaleBestseller No. 9
Brooks Mens Levitate 4 Running Shoe - Grey/Black/Capri - D - 11
  • THIS MEN'S SHOE IS FOR: The Levitate 4 is perfect for runners who want a shoe that helps them by giving energy back with each step, the Levitate 4's DNA AMP is now 20% lighter so our highest energy return foam is better than ever.
  • ENERGIZED CUSHIONING: Now 20% lighter, our DNA AMP midsole technology lets your foot spring off the ground with each step for speedy, efficient energy return.
  • SECURE, SOCK-LIFE FIT: We updated the Fit Knit Upper to provide a close-to-foot fit that’s lighter, softer, and more breathable than before. The Levitate 4 runs more shallow and provides a slightly more snug fit. If looking for a more roomy fit, Brooks recommends sizing up by 1/2 a size
  • QUICK TRANSITIONS: An updated arrow-point pattern on the outsole lets your foot move from heel to toe quickly, enhancing the shoe’s springy feel.
  • WEAR TESTERS SAY: “ I loved the energy I felt when running in these. Great cushion and ride.”
SaleBestseller No. 10
Brooks Mens Levitate 4 Running Shoe - Grey/Black/Capri - D - 10
  • THIS MEN'S SHOE IS FOR: The Levitate 4 is perfect for runners who want a shoe that helps them by giving energy back with each step, the Levitate 4's DNA AMP is now 20% lighter so our highest energy return foam is better than ever.
  • ENERGIZED CUSHIONING: Now 20% lighter, our DNA AMP midsole technology lets your foot spring off the ground with each step for speedy, efficient energy return.
  • SECURE, SOCK-LIFE FIT: We updated the Fit Knit Upper to provide a close-to-foot fit that’s lighter, softer, and more breathable than before. The Levitate 4 runs more shallow and provides a slightly more snug fit. If looking for a more roomy fit, Brooks recommends sizing up by 1/2 a size
  • QUICK TRANSITIONS: An updated arrow-point pattern on the outsole lets your foot move from heel to toe quickly, enhancing the shoe’s springy feel.
  • WEAR TESTERS SAY: “ I loved the energy I felt when running in these. Great cushion and ride.”

I get commissions for purchases made through links on this website. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.