Causes of Higher Risk of Stress Fractures in Female Runners

Press Release:

PHILADELPHIA – Running is one of the most popular forms of exercise, enjoyed by a broad range of age groups and skill levels.  More women are running recreationally compared to men; specifically 54% of runners are female as indicated by a 2018 National Runner Survey. Women, however, are at least twice as likely as men to develop stress fractures, an injury that impacts around 20% of runners. However, information is still lacking on how to best prevent and treat stress fractures in women. New pilot research from Jefferson suggests physiological factors that could be included in routine screening for stress fracture risk, as well as changes in training approach to aid in prevention.

The researchers examined physiological differences that might contribute to increased risk of stress fractures in a study published in Sports Healthand also surveyed women’s perception of risk and behaviors that contribute to stress fractures in a separate study published in Physical Therapy in Sport

“Most of the literature focuses on elite runners or athletes,” says Therese Johnston, PT, PhD, MBA, Professor in the Department of Physical Therapy and first author of both studies. “It was important for us to capture the regular or average female runner in these studies, and the main goal was to see how we can prevent a first or subsequent fracture.”

Both studies surveyed the same group of 40 female recreational runners, age 18-65 years. 20 women had a history of running-related stress fractures, and they were matched according to age and running abilities with 20 women with no history of stress fractures. The two studies aimed to assess what contributed to risk of stress fractures, from the physiological, such as – bone structure and density, muscle mass, hormonal status, to ones influenced by training routine, such as training intensity, nutrition, insufficient strengthening, and ignoring pain.

“This mixed methods approach provides a richer context and a more detailed picture of the practices and risks that contribute to stress fractures in every-day women runners,” says Jeremy Close, MD, associate professor in family and sports medicine and one of the lead authors on the research. “It also tells us how perceived risk informs physiological risk.”

For the study focused on physiological factors, the subjects underwent a comprehensive blood panel that examined levels of hormones like estradiol and testosterone, vitamins and minerals important for bone health such as vitamin D and calcium, and bone markers. They also underwent dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DXA) to test for bone mineral density. The researchers found that while there was no difference in estradiol hormone levels between the two groups, women who had a stress fracture history reported menstrual changes or irregular periods as a result of their training, or during peak training times. The blood panel also examined markers for bone formation and resorption, and pointed to increased bone turnover in the group of women with stress fractures. They also found through the DXA testing that women with a history of stress fractures had lower hip bone mineral density compared to women with no history of stress fractures, indicating decreased bone strength that could increase risk of injury.

“DXA for bone density and blood testing for bone markers are not routinely performed in this population – they are usually reserved for post-menopausal women – so we may be missing important clinical indicators for stress fractures in these women,” says Dr. Johnston. “While the link between menstrual changes and bone strength is unclear, our findings also indicate that asking female runners about any menstrual irregularities during heavier training times is important during routine screening.”

For the study investigating women’s self-perception of risk, interviews were conducted with the goals of finding out which factors women thought were associated with stress fractures or maintaining bone health while running. Several themes emerged from these interviews. Specifically, compared to women without stress fractures, women with histories of stress fractures had increased their training load more quickly. Also, while they knew of the importance of nutrition and strengthening exercises, women with a history of stress fracture more often reported not having or making the time for a balanced diet and proper cross-training to complement their running regimen.

Finally, women in this group reported pushing through the pain and running despite an injury more often than those without stress fracture. “In the interviews, it sounded like these women had trouble knowing which pain was normal, and which pain was abnormal. They also reported not always receiving appropriate guidance from healthcare providers on how to progress running safely,” says Dr. Johnston.

“It is clear that there needs to be more guidance from healthcare providers for woman runners on how to prevent stress fractures” says Dr. Close. “It can be very frustrating for these women who are on a path to wellness, but are impeded by an injury that can take several months to heal. If they don’t have the proper guidance on how to return to running safely, they risk a second injury.”

“We hope that our findings will encourage more thorough and routine screening in women runners for bone density and strength,” says Dr. Johnston, “as well as a comprehensive education plan on how to balance running with cross-training, and how to interpret pain cues from the body, to help women differentiate between normal aches and pains and indicators of a serious injury.”

Dr. Johnston plans to continue this research by studying women with acute stress fractures as they start running again, in order to identify factors related to successful or unsuccessful return to running following a stress fracture. The study will include Dr. Close as well as Marc Harwood, MD, service chief in the department of non-operative sports medicine at Rothman Orthopaedic Institute.

The work was funded by the Thomas Jefferson University Office of the Provost. The authors report no conflict of interest

Advertisement:

Bestseller No. 1
BraceAbility Post-op Shoe for Broken Foot or Toe | Medical/Surgical Walking Shoe Cast Boot, Stress Fracture Brace & Orthopedic Sandal with Hard Sole (Large - Female)
  • BEFORE YOU BUY: Please view our sizing chart (the 2nd image above). The male and female post-op shoes fit US men's, women's, and certain big kid's shoe sizes. Can be worn on your right or left foot. Female Large weighs 11 ounces.
  • ROCKER SOLE & NON-SKID TREAD: Non-slip traction on the rubber sole provides extra stability after surgeries for broken toes, bunions, hammer toes, Plantar fasciitis, etc. The rigid rocker bottom supports the arch and relieves pain and pressure on the forefoot and heel for a more natural step.
  • INNOVATIVE STRAPPING & SQUARE-TOE DESIGN: Providing a safe and secure fit, three adjustable medical-grade fastener straps easily accommodate bandaging and swelling. A square toe box acts as a bumper to protect the toes.
  • COMFORTABLE IMMOBILIZATION: Semi-open style and airflow-friendly material provides enhanced breathability for all-day comfort during rehabilitation. The lightweight, orthopedic foam insole provides cushioning and shock absorption for a quick recovery.
  • POST SURGICAL PROTECTION: Keeping dressings, bandages, and casts dry and clean, this post op shoe provides excellent support and protection after an injury or surgery on the toe, foot, ankle or leg.
Bestseller No. 2
Stress Fractures: Biblical Splints for Everyday Pressures
  • Swindoll, Charles R (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 273 Pages - 06/04/1990 (Publication Date) - Multnomah (Publisher)
Bestseller No. 4
BraceAbility Short Air Ankle Walker Boot | Medical-Grade Orthopedic Foot Cast Brace for Sprained Ankle, Broken Foot, Toe Injury, Metatarsal Stress Fracture, Post Surgery, Achilles Tendonitis (Small)
  • BEFORE PURCHASING please view our size chart (the 2nd image above). Size SMALL fits U.S. Men's shoe sizes 6-8 and U.S. Women's shoe sizes 6.5-9. Can be worn on your RIGHT OR LEFT FOOT. Small weighs 1 pound 12 ounces.
  • CUSTOMIZABLE AIRCELL TECHNOLOGY for personalized compression and enhanced stability during your recovery process.
  • HELPS TREAT & PROTECT an ankle sprain, broken toe, metatarsal stress fracture, Achilles tendonitis, bunionectomy, or anytime you need to immobilize your foot following an injury or surgery.
  • DELUXE FOAM LINER & ROCKER SOLE help absorb plantar shock and promote a more natural step.
  • RIGID, POLYMER PLASTIC reinforced shell provides protection and support on both sides of your foot and ankle.
Bestseller No. 5
Post Op Recovery Shoe - Adjustable Medical Walking Shoe for Post Surgery or Operation Support, Broken Foot or Toe, Stress Fractures, Bunions, or Hammer Toe for Left or Right Foot by Brace Direct
  • ✔LIGHTWEIGHT, BREATHABLE Shock Absorbing EVA Sole for maximum airflow and cushion for a faster recovery and no skin irritation.
  • ✔ROCKER BOTTOM SOLE and Non Skid Tread supports provides superior stability and arch support while relieving pain and pressure on the forefoot and heel for a more natural step.
  • ✔COMFORTABLE IMMOBILIZATION and breath-ability for an all-day usage and full recovery. Square open toe prevents bumping and toe protection.
  • ✔INNOVATIVE Adjustable 3 medical grade strap system to ensure a safe and secure fit while accommodating fluctuation of bandaging and swelling. Completely VERSATILE and may be worn on either left or right foot.
  • ✔PERFECT FIT GUARANTEE: Visit Brace.Direct to schedule your appointment with an experienced team member for a free video fitting and adjustment session to achieve the perfect fit.
Bestseller No. 6
EXCEART 1 Pair Post op Shoe Medical Surgical Walking Shoe Cast Boot Stress Fracture Brace Orthopedic Sandal Size 43
  • procare surgical shoe post op sandal post surgery footwear post operative footwear
  • Post op Shoe Medical Surgical Walking Shoe Cast Boot Stress Fracture Brace Orthopedic Sandal
  • Mesh Cloth Shoes Adjustable Magical Sticker Shoes Indoor Floor Shoes Breathable Nursing Shoes for Men Women Wearing
  • Bring comfort, warmth and an irresistible soft touch to your feet, This shoes has the feature of soft and sturdy, and it has soft and durable soles.
  • post surgery shoe post foot shoes procare shoe post op walking shoe procare surgical shoe post op sandal
SaleBestseller No. 7
Stress Fractures in Athletes: Diagnosis and Management
  • Hardcover Book
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 298 Pages - 07/04/2020 (Publication Date) - Springer (Publisher)
Bestseller No. 8
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy For Anxiety: How To Finally Break Free From Anxiety And Change Your Life Forever
  • Moran, Jonathan (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 149 Pages - 01/05/2019 (Publication Date) - Independently published (Publisher)
Bestseller No. 10
Stress Fracture (Dub Walker Thriller)
  • Lyle, D P (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 316 Pages - 01/29/2020 (Publication Date) - Suspense Publishing (Publisher)

I get commissions for purchases made through links on this website. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.